Affiliated Fair Scientific Review Committee (SRC) Checklist for Project Reviews
An SRC is responsible for reviewing and approving research projects at each step of the process as required by the International Rules & Guidelines. This includes three key periods of time: 1) Preapproval of projects involving sensitive areas such as humans, vertebrate animals or potentially hazardous biological agents to ensure safety of all involved prior to the start of experimentation; 2) Review just prior to competition required for all projects competing to ensure eligibility and compliance with the rules for fair and just competition; and 3) Review and documentation for projects advancing to the next level of competition, most especially when advancing to the Regeneron ISEF. The following is a suggested checklist for each phase of review.
I. SRC PRE-APPROVAL BEFORE EXPERIMENTATION
Most proposed research projects involving human participants, vertebrate animals and/or potentially hazardous biological agents must be reviewed and approved BEFORE experimentation.
In the pre-approval of a project, the SRC is making a determination that:
- the project design is in compliance with International Rules,
- the student researcher has considered risks and articulated safety precautions
- the student(s) will have proper supervision and
- the student will conduct the experiment under proper laboratory or field conditions.
It is fully within the rights of the SRC and an expectation of this pre-review that the SRC will provide feedback to the student(s) and their Adult Sponsor about elements of the project that must be clarified or modified or removed to receive approval. Such approval should not be granted until concerns are addressed and the SRC has full confidence that the project will comply with the rules and keep the student researcher(s) safe.
Here are key questions to consider:
1. Does the proposed research plan clearly detail all elements of the project to be conducted?
The proposed research plan should address:
- The Rationale for the project
- Research Question/Engineering Goal
- List of materials: Include any chemicals, potentially hazardous biological agents (PHBAs), or hazardous activities or devices; ensure an SDS has been consulted when appropriate.
- Procedures/Methodology: Detail all procedures and steps of the experimental design including methods for data collection, and when applicable, the source of data used. Be sure to differentiate steps to be taken by the student and steps to be taken by any supervising adult(s).
- Risk and Safety: Identify any potential risks and describe safety precautions to be taken. As appropriate this should include details about training, laboratory environment, supervision, personal protective equipment (PPE), and/or proper disposal methods.
- Data Analysis: Describe the procedures you will use to analyze the data/results.
- Acknowledgements: Is the student clear about the support being received and how AI is to be used?
- Bibliography: Is there evidence of a literature review and has the student properly cited?
If the project involves vertebrate animals, the research plan should also:
- Discuss potential ALTERNATIVES to vertebrate animal use and present justification for use of vertebrates.
- Explain potential impact or contribution of this research.
- Detail all procedures to be used, including methods used to minimize potential discomfort, distress, pain and injury to the animals and detailed chemical concentrations and drug dosages.
- Detail animal numbers, species, strain, sex, age, source, etc., include justification of the numbers planned.
- Describe housing and oversight of daily care. o Discuss disposition of the animals at the end of the study.
If the project involves potentially hazardous biological agents (PHBAs):
- Give source of the organism and describe BSL assessment process and BSL determination.
- Detail safety precautions and discuss methods of disposal.
2. Does the project have appropriate supervision?
- Is it clear what elements of the project the student will do different from those to be done by the lab/mentor/qualified scientist or direct supervisor?
- Do the adults supporting the project have the training and/or expertise needed?
- If the project involves vertebrate animals, is there veterinary support and/or expertise necessary to ensure the proper care and handling of the animals?
3. Does the project have the appropriate experimental environment?
- This is especially important for any project involving PHBAs. Whether the lab must be a BSL-1 or BSL-2 will be dependent on the microorganisms to be used and the methodology proposed. The BSL Checklists can help determine if the lab is properly equipped. If the project requires BSL-2 conditions, the project must use the biosafety cabinet and other BSL-2 equipment in the laboratory and NOT conduct the project on the open bench. Ideally the student will have completed Forms 6A and 6B to provide clarity.
- If a student is working within a Regulated Research Institution (RRI), consulting with the Principal Investigator of the laboratory and/or receiving a statement of support and clarity of the student���s role in the laboratory and any limitations placed on their participation as it pertains to the use of PHBAs or vertebrate animals can be additional information helpful in making a final determination.
4. Does the project involve humans in any phase of the proposed plan?
- Are there any references to surveys, seeking opinions or consulting with potential users or testing? If so, an Institution Review Board (IRB) will need to also review the project prior to its start.
5. Will the project meet the eligibility requirements of competition?
- Are there no more than 3 members of a team? Do all student(s) meet the eligibility and geographical territory restrictions of your fair?
- Has the student done prior work in this area of research? If so, it might be a continuation and should articulate the differences in the proposed research plan from prior year���s work.
II. SRC REVIEW SHORTLY BEFORE COMPETITION
ALL projects, including those at an RRI, must be reviewed and approved by the SRC after experimentation and before competition in an Affiliated Fair.
A Scientific Review Committee (SRC) examines projects for the following:
- Has the student researcher and Adult Sponsor provided the correct documentation?
- Does the project meet all of the eligibility requirements for competition?
- Review the documentation provided to confirm proper team composition, eligible start and end dates, and a valid continuation, if applicable.
- Is the project compliant with:
- All of the tenets of the ethics statement?
- With the International Rules & Guidelines?
- With all rules and laws governing the use of humans, vertebrate animals, potentially hazardous biological agents, and/or hazardous chemicals, devices or activities?
- Is there evidence of appropriate supervision? Have safety precautions been addressed? Has the student properly disclosed all of the support received from adults and artificial intelligence?
- As specified by the project, confirm:
- Use of accepted and appropriate research techniques
- Appropriate laboratory setting and safety (particularly biosafety levels)
- Evidence that risks have been properly assessed
- Appropriate consent procedures for human participant studies
- Humane treatment of animals and appropriate husbandry
- Documentation of substantial expansion for continuation projects
- Evidence of appropriate literature search and proper citations.
The research plan along with the completed forms should address these questions.
All projects must have the following forms:
- Checklist for Adult Sponsor (1)
- Student Checklist (1A)
- Approval Form (1B)
- Student Support Disclosure Form (2A)
Additional forms are required for specialized areas of research. Please see the for a description of each form.
- All required forms should be completed and signed. Signatures should reflect the correct timeline of the project as relative to the actual start and end dates provided on Student Checklist Form 1A. (The start and end date on Student Checklist Form 1A must be provided.)
- The information on the forms should be in agreement with the detailed research plan and demonstrate:
- Proper supervision. Confirm that the adults supporting the project include individuals with the expertise required for the project.
- Additional Support Disclosure Forms 2A, 2B, 2C
- Research site. Confirm the project was conducted at the appropriate site, i.e. home/school/RRI and as appropriate, consider the biosafety level.
- Safety. Confirm that risks have been properly assessed and mitigated and safety precautions fully explained. Has the SDS been consulted and followed?
- If a Risk Assessment Form 3 has not been included and you are seeking more clarity, one may be requested and completed post-experimentation.
- Pre-approvals. Has the appropriate approval body(ies) reviewed the project and attested to their review BEFORE experimentation? This could be an IRB, IACUC, IBC or SRC as appropriate. Form 4 should be void of any conflicts of interest and demonstrate 3 signatures of the appropriate designated members of the IRB. Checkboxes of their decisions must be checked.
- Does the research plan provide appropriate detail? Is there a project summary that explains any changes made from the original plan?
- The abstract must reflect only student work of the current year and be free from acknowledgements.
- The Regulated Research Institutional (1C) or Industrial Setting Form (2C) must be completed by the adult researcher (not the student) and must be on the actual form.
- Continuation Form 7 must be accompanied by the abstract and research plan of the most immediate past year. To provide more clarity, an SRC may request to receive multiple years��� abstract and research plan.
III. REVIEW OF PROJECTS MOVING FORWARD TO NEXT LEVEL OF COMPETITION
At the conclusion of your affiliated fair, a few student winners will be moving on to the next level of competition ��� whether that is to a regional, state or country fair or to the Regeneron ISEF. The Affiliated Fair SRC is asked to support the review of the winning projects to ensure that the documentation sent forward is complete and accurately represents the project presented and the student(s) own work with appropriate attributions and citations.
- We recommend that the SRC review the documentation that they received just prior to competition and conduct a secondary review to ensure full compliance.
- Add the appropriate SRC approval signature to Approval Form 1B and share this signed document forward to your finalists advancing.
- Ask for clarity or more detailed information, particularly as a Project Summary so that the research plan properly reflects the project that competed at your fair.
- Remind and inform the student that additional research outside the scope of the research plan and the project that was presented at your fair is prohibited.
- Working with the fair director, adult sponsor and student finalists, verify that the finalist conducted the work as stated.
- Contact any/all of the adults provided within the fair paperwork and/or on the Student Disclosure Form 2A and ask for any clarifications of the student���s role.
- Verify with the student researcher that all support has been properly disclosed.